Lawrence Booth: England must stop Hughes Phill–ing his boots
May 13th, 2009 by Lawrence Booth in County cricket, Test cricket, The Ashes, middlesex
I’ve seen the future and it’s scary. It backs away to leg and hits good-length balls through point. It hurries down the pitch and whacks seamers over long-on. It is only 20 years old but has a better line in banter than one or two seasoned South African sledgers I could name. It’s name is Phillip Hughes, and unless England have a cunning plan to deal with it, they can kiss goodbye to the Ashes. Again.
Hughes is enough to make a God-fearing Englishman think the world is against him. When Matthew Hayden quit, he created a small chasm at the top of Australia’s order. Here was another weakness to add to a list already including “no spinner”, “temperamental all-rounder”, “fading Hussey” and “journeymen seamers”. But Hughes appears set to make Hayden look like an old frump. Where do they get them from?
In five hours and 20 minutes at The Oval last week, Hughes compiled – if that’s not too bland a verb – 195 out of 317 for Middlesex. That came on the back of 118 and 65 not out against Glamorgan and 139 against Leicestershire. These are not necessarily attacks to conjure with, but then the two hundreds Hughes made in his second Test, at Durban, suggest he can handle top-class bowling too. And if England make the mistake of inferring cowardice in that trademark step-away to leg, he will have 60 on the board before the truth dawns.
You see, it’s the way he plays, not just the runs he scores, that is so enchanting. Towards the end of the game against Glamorgan at Lord’s, Middlesex faced a tricky final 20 overs or so after losing three quick second-innings wickets. Most openers would have been inclined to block their way to safety. Hughes simply hit out, finishing with 65 out of a score of 94 for three and collecting nine of his side’s 11 boundaries. When it was pointed out to him on his return to the dressing room that there are other ways of playing for a draw, he replied: “You’ve got to have a bit of fun while you’re out there, haven’t you?”
Hughes is currently batting with something that goes beyond the fearlessness of youth. It isn’t arrogance (he says he is able to keep both feet on the ground). It isn’t recklessness (he has a system and it clearly works). It isn’t bravado (he is a humble interviewee). But it may just be a perfect-storm combination of several factors that do not often come together in a cricketer. Supreme confidence, lightning-fast hand-eye coordination, rare talent, impressive humility, utter diligence and – the writer’s get-out clause – the X-factor.
At some point things will go wrong for Hughes, and the critics will tuck into his unorthodoxy with relish. His challenge then will be to ignore them and trust in an approach that has brought him 10 first-class hundreds in 24 games. England’s challenge will be to prevent their natural suspicion of any technique that transcends the text-book from clouding their judgment. Accepting Hughes will be their first task. Overcoming him may be a different matter altogether.
Lawrence Booth writes on cricket for The Guardian. His third book, Cricket, Lovely Cricket? An Addict’s Guide to the World’s Most Exasperating Game is out now published by Yellow Jersey
Posted in County cricket, Test cricket, The Ashes, middlesex | 8 Comments »
May 13th, 2009 at 6:43 pm
The future sounds like Virender Sehwag. Which makes it just about the most exciting cricket in the world.
While Test sides around the world are using unorthodox, high-risk dashers at the top (Sehwag, Hughes, Gayle), England are with two admirable plodders.
I wonder if England’s continued batting woes are related to the lack of momentum at the top since Tresco left?
May 13th, 2009 at 11:24 pm
I think England should be happy to know Hughes is scoring so heavily at this time. The laws od average does not lie and he is due failure soon. For England’s sake, let’s hope it happens before the Ashes end.
May 14th, 2009 at 4:30 am
Hopefully. Phillip Hughes turns out to be the once in a generation player to replace the recently retired group of Gilchrist, McGrath and of course the great man SK Warne and the soon to be retired Ponting.
One swallow doesn’t make a summer, so young Phil’s very different technique is very has not yet survived the Test of time.
You are entitled to be scared and no one has found an answer yet….however history has shown us that there are ways to curb almost all batsman and it is only a matter of time before someone gets on to it.
Remember his first test innings?
May 14th, 2009 at 1:24 pm
It’s alright though, he’ll get found out eventually. He’s unorthodox, so he can’t possibly be successful.
He’ll never achieve the mind-numbingly average consistency of our batsmen without a technique copied and pasted from the MCC Coaching Manual.
May 14th, 2009 at 4:10 pm
Colin says:
May 13th, 2009 at 11:24 pm
I think England should be happy to know Hughes is scoring so heavily at this time. The laws od average does not lie and he is due failure soon.
……………………….
Don Bradman, anyone?
May 14th, 2009 at 4:54 pm
Wow.
Colin, Dave, The same same was said of Viv and Lara. Viv was unorthodox, whipping every thing to leg, etc.
Lara a high back lift, whatever.
They will find him out, but maybe in 15 yrs time. I am a west-indian but what i have read about Hughes and the way he gets his runs all over the place, with scant disregard to situations and opponents — Any similarities with Viv and Larawhen they started, beware.
May 15th, 2009 at 12:57 am
I saw a couple of innings he played against South Africa. They were simply audacious. He is young but his temperament seems superb. He is certainly a class act and i had a gut feeling way then that ASHES for England is gone and he shall be the biggest contributor in their demise. Mark it!!
Lets see what Swann can offer for England, because i have no expectation from their seemers. I am surprised Warney has some good words for him.
May 16th, 2009 at 9:54 am
I hope the English are not banking on troubling him with, for all practical purposes, dibbly-dobbly bowlers on less helpful pitches than the lords pitch they just played on.