Recent Comments

February 2010
M T W T F S S
« Jan   Mar »
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728

Benj Moorehead: Can Cook do a Strauss?

February 5th, 2010 by Benj Moorehead in England, International, Test cricket

co

Almost two years ago Andrew Strauss was brought back into the England team for the Test series against New Zealand. He struggled at first, before a grinding hundred in the second innings of the final Test to seal England’s series win. But who was this Strauss? Few were the searing offside shots that were a trademark. No, a bad run insisted caution now came first. Bowlers had to err considerably in line or length for Strauss to attack. Then, of course, he got better. In fact he eventually found the form of his life, scoring runs with intimidating conviction.

Alastair Cook may be having his Strauss-in-New Zealand moment. There are differences of course. Cook has never been a quick scorer. He hasn’t been dropped from the team. Indeed, he’s about to become a stand-in Test captain.

But, like Strauss, Cook is applying some technical adjustments. Like Strauss, he has ferociously reigned in his shots, notably in his weak area, the corridor. Good line and length outside off? Cook leaves. Again, again, and again.

Cook faced 625 balls in the South Africa Test series, 468 of them resulting in no run. Of his 287 runs, 31% of them came on the offside. Cook has always been keen on the onside, but to kick on he will surely have to present more of a problem to bowlers who, at present, know exactly where to spear the ball.

He has passed his first test: to succeed through caution and will. One hundred, two fifties and a series average of 41 prove it. Can he move to stage two of the Strauss process? Cook will never be known for his scoring rate but a policy of leaving almost everything outside off cannot be a lasting tactic. He must, like Strauss, use the disciplined innings of late as a source of confidence to ease his way into becoming a multi-dimensional Test cricketer.

But unlike Strauss, Cook’s critical phase comes just as he has been asked to captain the Test team in Bangladesh. It should have been the perfect tour at the perfect time for Cook the batsman: a low-key Test series against weaker opposition with the Ashes – and an Australian team who will mercilessly test that outside-off policy – looming at the end of the year. Instead he may see the two Bangladesh Tests as part-determining whether he will be a future England Test captain.

Good luck to him.

Benj Moorehead is editorial assistant of The Wisden Cricketer

Posted in England, International, Test cricket | 5 Comments »



5 Responses to “Benj Moorehead: Can Cook do a Strauss?”

  1.   Cricket Betting Blog says:

    Not wishing to look backwards, but what worries me about Alastair Cook and a lot of the other England players is that, for example, when Cook was out of form against the Aussies, he didn’t have the inkling to then reign in the shots that were troubling him?

    It wasn’t difficult to see what was wrong, so why did it take him so long to work it out?

    With regard to the SA series, you say he averaged 41, I assume that is around the mark of his overall average which says to me he only had an average series.

    All the pundits on Tele and Radio kept telling us what a great series he had, when the reality was that it was average.

    I’ll admit it was an improvement.

    And he was one of the better batsmen, there we have one of the reasons England didn’t win the series.

    As for now, maybe he would have been better using the Bangladesh series to bat his way into more good form, rather than worrying about being captain.

    The rights or wrongs of the Strauss decision is another argument, and one that will only be concluded after the Ashes has finished.

  2.   Mick Jones says:

    Cook is rubbish, scores too slowly for a modern-day Test opener and is mentally weak.

    no one thinks he has earner or deserved this captaincy.

    Benj – you know this as does the whole world. Move on mate.

    Oh and I didn’t even mention his fielding

  3.   Paddy Briggs says:

    The selectors have occasional moments of insanity ( Darren Pattinson anyone) but to be fair to them they can spot class. Cook is class – as was apparent from the moment he scored a double hundred against the Aussies in 2005. He is still work in progress – only 25 and with hopefully ten years of international cricket ahead of him. Good luck to him…

  4.   Paddy Briggs says:

    Now if only England had a player like the Saffers Alviro Petersen who scores a hundred in his first Test match – and in India as well! That would be something…

  5.   Winsome says:

    You sure he’s that good a quality batsman? Class looks like higher achievement levels by now. He’s been around a long time.

Leave a Reply

Site by Anson Robson Marketing © 2010 The Wisden Cricketer All Rights Reserved