As England and South Africa prepare to square-up at Lord’s the general consensus seems to be that England are going to take a high-octane beating this summer. At TWC we like to stay positive, so we’ve trawled the web to come up with five moments from the past 14 years that England have got one over on the Saffers. Enjoy.
1. Devon Malcolm takes 9 for 57, 5th Test, The Oval, 1994
Devon Malcolm’s England career was a cataclysmic mixture of searing pace, wasted potential, bad management, utter dross, and this. Like Senator Geary in the Godfather part II the South Africans’ bravado played the decisive part in their own downfall, as the normally placid Malcolm was moved to promise them “You guys are history” after Fanie de Villiers had had the temerity to thwack his helmet with a bouncer. He did not disappoint, reducing the tourists to 1 for 3, and claiming the first seven wickets to fall before Darren Gough finally spoilt his fun by dismissing Darryl Cullinan. Malcolm went on to claim nine - the first England bowler to do so since Jim Laker - as England dismissed South Africa for 175 and went on to square the series.
2. Mike Atherton scores 185*, 2nd Test, Johannesburg, 1995
If you delight in dour, dogged defiance then it doesn’t come much better than this. Athers gritted out 643 minutes, faced 492 balls and bored 11 South Africans to tears as he saved a Test that he had simply no right to. Chasing 479 to win, England had slumped to 167 for 4 by the close of the fourth day with Atherton unbeaten on 82. He would bat the whole of the fifth day, not without luck (Gary Kirsten dropped him on 99), but who cares about that? It was his finest seven hours – his definitive innings. That England still lost the series 2-0 goes some way to explaining his frustrations as captain of an ordinary England side.
3. Allan Donald works over Mike Atherton, 4th Test, Trent Bridge, 1998.
While Glenn McGrath rarely failed to get him out, in the mid-90s the South Africans just couldn’t shift Atherton. They arrived at Trent Bridge one up in the rubber with two Tests to play, with Allan Donald at the peak of his powers (he took 33 wickets at just 19 that summer). They left, demoralised, and level at 1-1 after an eight-wicket England win that had Atherton’s second-innings 98* stamped all over it. History remembers the result and its significance in a series that England won 2-1 but a lightning spell from Donald after Atherton had failed to walk overshadows everything else that happened in that Test.
“Vicious, really, really vicious,” says David Gower, with a wonderfully casual air of understatement after Donald had shaved Atherton’s ear from round the wicket at a shade over 90mph. “Between them they could write a book these two.” Atherton, it turned out, did.
Much has been written of my joust with Donald: some negative things, of umpiring decisions, of batsmen not walking, and sledging. Every person, however, that I’ve spoken to has seen it in a positive light and said it was some of the most compelling cricket they have seen. Enough said.
Atherton survived to lead England to their target of 247 and Donald’s misery was complete when Mark Boucher spilled a regulation catch from Nasser Hussain in the middle of the onslaught. To English fans it remains the great duel of modern times.
4. England beat South Africa, 3rd Test, Trent Bridge, 2003
The third Test at Trent Bridge was notable for far more than James Anderson’s ridiculous red hair, as England fought their way back into a series that Graeme Smith’s two double-centuries had dominated for South Africa. Fledgling skipper Michael Vaughan found solace in an unlikely source, James Kirtley, who took a second-innings 6 for 34 on debut to skid England to victory.
Under immense pressure after South Africa’s crushing victory by an innings-and-92 runs at Lord’s England responded positively, with Mark Butcher and Nasser Hussain scoring centuries in their first-innings 445. Andrew Flintoff then removed Smith for 35, a relative cameo, while Anderson claimed five wickets as England established a first-innings lead of 83 on a disintegrating pitch before the real drama began.
Shaun Pollock’s six wickets bowled England out for 118 but they still had a lead of 201, Kirtley struck early and South Africa were a nervous 50 for 5 at the start of the fifth day. This soon became 131 all out, as Kirtley and England wrapped up a 70-run victory before lunch. Wisden charitably record Kirtley having bowled ‘the odd shooter’ but Smith described the surface as the worst Test pitch he’d seen. England didn’t care, they were back in the summer.
5. Matthew Hoggard takes 7 for 61, 4th Test, The Wanderers, 2004
You cannot help but feel for Matthew Hoggard. As Andrew Flintoff, Simon Jones and even Steve Harmison push for recalls to the Test fold, Hoggard has plummeted from England’s main bowler to the forgotten man in five short months. At least, if he doesn’t play again, he can look back on spells like this.
Hoggard’s first innings 5 for 144 had come in a disappointing England fielding performance, they had a first-innings deficit of eight despite Andrew Strauss’ century. England tottered at 189 for 5 on the final morning, a draw was favourite, a South African victory a possibility. Then Marcus Trescothick smashed 180, changed the mood entirely and set South Africa a target of 325 in 68 overs.
From then, it was all Hoggard. South Africa were quickly 18 for 3 as even the monolithic Jacques Kallis came and went first ball. The first six to fall were all Hoggard’s as England battled against the clock and the darkness, before Herschelle Gibbs and the injured Graeme Smith came together in a seventh-wicket partnership that looked destined to deny England. When Hoggard finally induced an edge from last-man Dale Steyn, England had won, Hoggard had taken seven in the innings and 12 in the match – and the catalyst for one of England’s great Test victories.
Sam Collins is web editor of www.thewisdencricketer.com